I found the recipe for this Mincemeat Ice-Cream Cake after making Mincemeat Cookies last Christmas – I guess after not seeing or hearing about mincemeat pie filling for years, I was seeing it everywhere. This year, I used mincemeat pie filling to do some other baking, and when I had some left over, I wanted to find a way to use it up. I came across this recipe in an old cookbook that I’ve had since I was 12 years old – talk about old-fashioned! You can see by this photo of when I was about 4 years old – I loved Christmas. And apparently white fluffy stuffed kittens (which is a funny gift to have gotten because my mom hated cats in any form)! And baking – Christmas baking – but sometimes you need an easy recipe or two just to keep up with it all and make it easy on yourself.
That’s why I like this recipe. This is a great make-ahead dessert – easy to do, fast to make, and ready in the freezer when you need it! It has an old-fashioned kind of feel to it because mincemeat pie is an old-fashioned kind of pie. Using mincemeat gives a Christmas flavor to the dessert that’s really made for our fast-paced holidays. I love things you can have ready ahead of time, I love easy, and I love this recipe!
Here is the recipe as I made it:
Mincemeat Ice-Cream Cake
Cut lengthwise into 3 even layers:
1 sponge, angel, or pound cake (I used a small frozen pound cake)
Stir to soften:
1 quart vanilla ice cream
Fold in:
1 cup prepared mincemeat (I used store bought, but you could use homemade, too)
1/2 cup slivered, blanched almonds, toasted (I used sliced almonds)
1/2 teaspoon grated orange peel
Spread between the cake layers and freeze firm (I put the layers back into the foil pan the cake cake in and froze it in there).
Before serving, spread top and sides with:
1 cup heavy cream, whipped
Trim with sliced almonds and maraschino cherries.
I used the foil pan to put the cake back in to freeze, but first I put in some plastic wrap so it would be easier to get out later. Put in a layer of cake, a half of the ice cream, a layer of cake, the other half of the ice cream, and the last layer of cake. Cover with the plastic wrap and freeze. If you don’t know exactly when you’re going to use the cake, cover the whole thing with foil to give it a little more protection.
When I was ready to frost the cake, I took a slice off of the top because I thought it might be too high when frosting it with the whipped cream. I don’t really know why I thought that, and I found that it really wasn’t necessary.
Whipped cream makes a nice frosting for this cake.
At first I thought I’d just use sprinkles to decorate.
Oh, what the heck. I went ahead and used the sliced almonds and maraschino cherries to make flowers on top of it, too. Can you really ever have too much decoration? Can you ever make things too festive? I think not!
It’s really a pretty elegant dessert, for a make-ahead.
This cake has that delicious flavor of the mincemeat along with the freshness of the orange peel, and it is absolutely delicious! Anything this easy to make, and is make-ahead to boot, is ok in my book. This dessert screams Christmas, and any guests or even your family will love this delicious Mincemeat Ice-Cream Cake!